Oklahoma wild animal zookeeper Joe Exotic fights to get out of prison and intensifies his feud with Carole Baskin, while the jury foreman exclusively explains the guilty verdict and an investigation reveals Carole's husband's will may be a forgery.

An ex-boyfriend believes Carole cares more about her animals than most people, while a former homicide cop explores property transfers from Carole to handyman Kenneth Farr and searches a lake for Don's body and a meat grinder.

Joe Exotic seeks a presidential pardon and keeps his spirits buoyed behind bars with the love of his husband and fan letters, as Don Lewis's handyman is confronted with allegations about his disappearance and Don's family seeks answers and closure.