Nestled halfway between Bangor and the Canadian border, Webster Plantation, ME, has a population of less than 70 people. When two of its residents, Michael and Valerie Miller, are found brutally murdered in their home, fear overwhelms everyone in town.

A tight-knit Illinois farming town is rocked when a family of five is found beaten to death in their home. When the bodies of the Gee family are discovered, the tiny town of Beason, IL, finds itself in the midst of a gruesome murder mystery.

Eighteen-year-old Kelly Eckart disappears one night after finishing up her shift at a local hardware store in Boggstown, IN. Hours later, her car is discovered abandoned by the side of the road, still running, but Kelly is nowhere to be found.

When elderly couple Charles and Grace Lewis vanish from the family farm along with their pickup truck, their children realize that something is terribly wrong. As word spreads, fear envelopes the quiet religious community of Bonne Terre, MO.

When teenager Bridgett Frisbie sneaks out of her Katy, TX, home one night, her parents assume it's just typical teenage rebellion. But the next day, a group of boys find her body in the woods just outside of town.

When beloved local business owner, 65-year-old Harvey Fuson, is murdered while minding his store in idyllic Cumberland Gap, TN, no one wants to think that the killer could be one of their own. Could the killer have been a stranger or someone a little closer to home?